Both Sides Discuss Dispute Over Elk Shooting By Jerry Sena Editor’s Note: Some readers believed a full-page advertisement appearing in the Thursday, May 18 edition of The Mountain Times, which concerned the below-stated dispute was a news story. All paid advertisements which are of a political nature or which comment on a news-related issue, will always include a notice that it is a paid advertisement, usually at the top or bottom of the ad.   A full-page newspaper ad purchased by a Bethel elk rancher has revived a controversy over state efforts to contain a potentially devastating disease among the state’s wild elk and deer herds. Wildlife enforcement officers served a search warrant March 28 on Joey Perdue, owner of Beaverhorn Elk Ranch. The story was subsequently reported in The Mountain Times. The search warrant, signed by Superior Court judge James Baker, allowed wildlife management officials to “seize” five elk, the last remnants of Perdue’s herd, after a citation accused her of failing to comply with state regulations. By “seize,” however, the warrant was really empowering officials to kill the elk. Officials disposed of their carcasses in a pit at the Wilkes Wildlife Depot. Perdue said she never believed her animals would be killed while Wildlife officials could not cite any documented instance where the threat of death is explicitly stated. Perdue said wildlife officials never told her that the violations would end in the death of her elk, which included a 23-year-old bull and three pregnant cows. What’s worse, she said, is the animals, which officials say were killed as part of the state’s effort to keep a mysterious brain ailment known as Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) from infecting wild herds, were rendered inedible when two veterinarians tranquilized them before killing them with a bolt-gun shot to the brain. “This waste amounted to approximately 5,000 pounds of the most healthy meat in the world,” an infuriated Perdue wrote in a letter to The Mountain Times. Much of the letter appeared in a paid advertisement by Perdue in the Thursday, May 18 edition of The Mountain Times. A Long Dispute Perdue had been involved in a running dispute with state Wildlife Management officials who said they’d been after the rancher since 2004 to bring her operation into what they called compliance with state law. When contacted by The Mountain Times in April, Brad Gunn, assistant chief of the Wildlife Management Division of the state’s Wildlife Resources Commission, said, “The agency has gone to great lengths to try to accommodate her and been unsuccessful. In my opinion she was given ample warning and opportunity to work something out.” Perdue acknowledged she’d failed to comply with strict rules adopted by the state in 2002 when CWD, or transmissible spongiform encephalopathy – an affliction biologists have compared to Mad Cow Disease in cattle – appeared to leap the Mississippi River into eastern regions it had never infected before. Gunn said the emergency rules were enacted in 2002 following discovery of “pretty reliable information” that deer infected with CWD had been imported from Wisconsin to North Carolina’s captive herds. Perdue’s elk tested negative for CWD and no sign of the disease has ever been documented in the state, though. Gunn said wildlife officials have maintained an aggressive program to see that it stays that way. The rules have undergone “challenges and tweaks along the way,” though, Gunn explained. And the legislature has passed laws allowing certain animals to be grandfathered in. Perdue’s herd was among those given special consideration, Gunn said, when it was exempted from new rules requiring fences be raised from eight to 10 feet in height. Public Health vs. Rancher’s Rights But Kelly Douglas, who leads the state’s captive herd program, said Perdue had failed to keep proper records. When officials showed up last month to kill her elk, one animal, a 10-month-old calf, had never been accounted for. Douglas said Perdue’s animals had not been tagged according to the 2002 rules, either. And a shed inside the animals’ enclosure was required by law to be walled on three sides. Perdue said state officials are “…ignorant. They know absolutely nothing about elk.” Enclosing the animals on three sides goes against their instinct for open spaces, she insisted. “If it’s snowing outside, the elk want to be right out there laying down in the snow. They don’t want to be inside a building,” she said. Perdue said she’d refused to tag her elk because doing so would have required she tranquilize the massive animals, an action she deemed too risky, especially for the 23-year-old bull she and her late husband had owned since the ranch’s 1983 founding. Douglas said Perdue should have known that seizing the animals was the equivalent of a death sentence. She said all participants in their captive elk and deer programs are informed repeatedly of the necessity of killing the animals to test for CWD. They’re also informed that all animals seized by Wildlife are required to be tested for the disease. The animals are tested whether or not they show any symptoms of CWD, which can have an incubation period as long as five years during which the infected animal may spread the disease to others it contacts, Douglas said. Capt. Bill Townsend, supervisor for District 7, which includes Watauga County and Beaverhorn Elk Ranch within its borders, said his office tries not to use blunt language because often the owners have come to see their animals as pets. “Of course we’re dealing with people who are very emotional,” he said. “I’m not trying to conceal what’s going to happen. I wouldn’t have driven up there into her driveway and told her, ‘Mrs. Perdue, we’re going to shoot a bolt through the head of your deer.’” Gunn said he would be “astounded” if enforcement officials had failed to inform Perdue of the consequences of non-compliance. “We’ve had a number of individuals who decided not to comply — whether for financial or other reasons  — they voluntarily surrendered their animals and there was no problem.”